Joho the Blog » FCC’s Net Neutrality discussion board

FCC’s Net Neutrality discussion board

The FCC has put up a site — openinternet.gov — where anyone (after registering with a valid email address) can post an idea, or vote existing ideas up or down. I love the idea of the feds opening discussions up, although, I am not convinced that this particular implementation achieves its presumed aims. But, what the heck! Try-fail-try is the right rhythm for the Net.

The site defaults to listing the ideas reverse chronologically, which adds some serendipity, or you can choose to view them listed in order of popularity, which encourages piling on. You can also browse by category/tag.

Anyone who registers can post a comment. The comments are unthreaded, discouraging much development of ideas but also discouraging flaming. You can report a comment as being “abusive,” but otherwise cannot rate them.

At the moment, the most popular posting is from Tim Karr, who, according to his biography at SaveTheInternet.com, a site sponsored by FreePress.net, “oversees all Free Press campaigns and online outreach efforts, including SavetheInternet.com.” Tim — who I know a bit and like — is an activist. He has the most popular post at the FCC’s site presumably because FreePress.net sent out a mailing urging supporters to vote it up.

There’s absolutely nothing wrong with that. It’s how politics is played in this country. If an anti-NN group sponsored by, say, AT&T wanted to play the same game, it’s perfectly entitled to. It’s not hard to imagine a well-funded group swamping FreePress’s shoestring efforts and getting orders of magnitudes more people to thumbs-up an anti-NN comment.

Which is to say that an open discussion board like the one the FCC has posted can serve either of two purposes. It can be a place where people come for rational discussions across political positions, or it can serve as an informal poll of citizens’ sentiments about an issue. But combining the two means that neither works very well. It becomes simply an opportunity for gaming the system.

It seems to me that sites such as these cannot serve as a poll that has any value at all. Besides, we have lots of other ways of gauging public opinion, including scientific polling and elections. If, on the other hand, the FCC wants to sponsor a forum for useful discussion or to generate new ideas, it could modify the current implementation. For example — and these are just ideas that may turn out to be gigantic belly flops — comments could be divided into two tracks, pro and con, with most-popular listings for each. Readers could be allowed to vote up but not down. Comments could be threaded. The comments could be rated. Postings could have buttons for “agree/disagree” and “interesting,” so that the site could highlight articles that people disagree with but find interesting.

All of these techniques could be gamed because everything can be gamed. Some discussion boards do work, though. I don’t know what the magic keys are, but I’m pretty confident that a political discussion board that includes an overall popularity contest will so encourage gaming that its results will necessarily be unreliable. At the very least, the popularity contest should be confined to determining the best arguments for each side.

But I don’t want to close on a negative note, for the FCC is to be congratulated on its efforts to open its processes up not only to lobbyists and geeks who know how to walk and talk like an FCC commenter, but to the general public. And it’s doing so in the proper Webby way of taking small steps and not being afraid to fail in public. That takes guts.

One Response to “FCC’s Net Neutrality discussion board”

  1. 72]Free Ringtones!

    http://fastloannow.ru/ringtones/ringtones-15.jpg

    72]Download Ringtones!

    free full ringtones
    k342 ringtones
    military jet ringtones
    cats ring tones
    ringtones telus

    Aquateen Hunger Force Ringtone
    Program Ringtone Samsung Cell Phone
    Normal Telephone Ringtone
    Free Ringtones For Motorola V260
    Free Ring Tones Without Texting
    Sstupid Ringtones
    Bad Farm Animals Ringtone
    Mercer Ringtones
    Palm Centro Add Ringtones
    Free Polyphonic Ringtones Motorola Phones
    Verizon Ringtone Verizon Ringtone
    A800 Ringtone Samsung
    Free Spooky Ringtones
    Free Ringtone Create Download
    Free Audiovox 8910 Ringtones
    Free Sprint Pcs A740 Ringtones
    Create Ringtone 4.96 Cracks
    Ringtones Get Smart
    Programs To Download Ringtones
    Motorola 332 Free Ring Tones
    Free Treo Ring Tones
    Free I730 Ringtone Wallpaper
    Dancehall Ringtones
    Ringtone For Windows Mobile Device
    Free Pyt Ringtones
    Free Ringtone For Samsung A660
    Ringtone Dont Taz Me Bro
    Ring Tones For Cingular Customers
    Edgar Winter Group Ringtones
    How To Un-lock Ringtones
    Ringtones Chevrolet 383
    Kottonmouth Kings Ringtones With Checks
    Voice Record Ringtones Lg Shine
    Ringtones And Pic
    Free Ringtone For Nextel Phone I95cl
    Lasgo Ringtone
    Ringtones For Nokia Tmobile
    Hot Ringtones For Us Cellular
    Free Ringtone For Sprint Pcs Phone
    Delete System Ringtones
    Camaro Ringtone
    Classic Ringtones
    Price Is Right Loser Ringtone
    Free Download Net 10 Ringtones
    V60s Ringtones
    Paramore Misery Business Ringtones
    Samsung T429 Ringtones
    Ringtones Torrent For Virgin Mobile
    Ne-yo Ringtones For Boost Mobile
    Athf Ringtone
    Upload Ringtones Remove Protected Media
    Carol Of The Bells Ringtones
    All Ringtones For Verizon Motorola V710
    Tarzan Ring Tone
    Picture Messages T720 Free Download Ringtones
    Rich Little Ring Tones
    Free Marine Corps Ringtone
    Nextel Ring Tone Downloads
    Free Nextel Ringtone Wallpaper

    nokia acc funny ringtones
    get low ring tone
    ringtone software for mac
    mp3 rap ringtone
    free great big sea ringtones
    bosuns pipe ringtone
    nextel webjal ringtone with
    christian music ringtones en espanol
    deftones passenger ringtone
    tomibile error ringtone
    free ringtones for verizon cellular phones
    music tones ringtones
    verizon wireless ringtones samsung
    ring tones for ericsson cell phones
    jpop ringtones cingular razr
    free uscellular ringtones
    free sprint katana ringtones
    free keypress ringtones sony ericsson t226
    free hip hop ringtones for sprint
    prepaid cell phone ring tones
    realtones ring tones mobile phones
    the pussycat dolls ringtones
    free ringtones tracfones

Leave a Reply


Web Joho only

Comments (RSS).  RSS icon