Joho the Blog » Deep thoughts (alphabetical)

Deep thoughts (alphabetical)

If Hollywood put up a big “Marilyn Monroe” sign, it would make sense for you to say that you snuck up there last night and switched the “M’s.”

If you type the name “Marilyn Monroe” and then copy and drag the M’s to transpose them, we would agree that you switched the M’s … but when you save the file and reopen it, are the M’s are still switched?

28 Responses to “Deep thoughts (alphabetical)”

  1. The M’s are still switched.

    The fact that the representations are identical and that it isn’t possible upon subsequent forensic analysis to determine that they have been switched is irrelevant.

    Similarity does not cause information to collapse into singularity.

    Unfortunately, many people think that indistinguishably similar digital representations of an intellectual work are the SAME work. They are not. They remain distinct copies (albeit indistinguishably similar).

    It is the privilege of copyright that gives people the notion that they can continue to supernaturally possess their intellectual work, wherever it exists in the universe, simply on the basis of similarity.

  2. The M’s aren’t the same M’s from before, so no, the new M’s are not the old ones switched.

    The M’s in play are just ephemeral representations of letters and their encoding in digital storage bears no resemblance to their visual form. Saving and restoring undergoes two one-way transformations and the reconstitution of the result is more like projection than teleportation.

    An analog would be that if you construct the name Marilyn Monroe on a flat surface with small pebbles, move the M’s, then take a photo of it, store it on an SSD card, and later reconstruct the image from the saved representation from the same pile of pebbles, there is nothing in the saved information to guarantee the letters would be constructed the same as the first time.

  3. Framed another way, if one typed “Marilyn Monroe,” on a computer saved the file, and then reopened it, are the reopened Ms the same as the originally typed Ms?

    I would say no, because of the nature of representation of computer-based information. Since all represented information is ephemeral (one of the properties of digitality), the representation has a time component among its characteristics. Thus the reopened Ms (as well as the other letters) are not the same in an existential sense as the ones of the originally typed file. Hence, in the example cited (which attempts to force an analogue between a tangible, concrete sign with an ephemeral production), the switched Ms are not the same Ms, and the retrieved file are certainly not the same Ms.

  4. P.S. You cannot step twice into the same river.

  5. Sheesh.

    Look, let us pretend that it was Micky Nouse. Swap the initial letters around to get Nicky Mouse, save the file, reload it, the letters remain swapped.

    Why do folk suddenly start invoking all sorts of supernatural and metaphysical nonsense simply because the initial letters are indistinguishable?

    What matters here is the provenance of information, the path of its communication. The fact that the end states are indistinguishable is irrelevant. Sure, a computer might say “Hang on. The new filename is equal to the existing one, therefore I won’t bother changing it”, but that is an optimisation – one I assume we are discounting for the sake of this thought experiment.

    I call it copy blindness. See A Cure for Copy-Blindness.

  6. Oh my god, I’ll never copy and paste again…

  7. I would say the M’s are in the eye of the beholder

  8. Crosbie, in your Micky Nouse example, it is true that the reloaded file has *an M* and *an N* transposed. They, are not, however, *the M* and *the N* from before. If you are going to get all literal on us and dismiss our arguments as supernatural and metaphysical nonsense, it’s incongruous then to deny a purely literal interpretation of the question.

  9. Just to overextend the thought experiment, if I were to tell you that I may or may not have switched the M’s and that the probability of my having done so is exactly 0.5, would you feel compelled by the ghost of Schrödinger to declare that the M’s are simultaneously switched and not switched?

  10. Brent,

    All you have to do is start off with the interchange of A & B, then A & A*, then A & A’, and finally A & A.

    Why on earth should things suddenly change simply because you are interchanging symbols that have the same representation?

    No magic occurs simply because A is equal to A, whereas A is not equal to A’. The laws of information are unconcerned with equality. If you swap A with A the same thing happens as with the exchange of A with A’,

    As far as Schrödinger is concerned, I will concede to you if you are talking of quantum computers. I am assuming Von Neuman architectures.

  11. It amuses me that you would express incredulity (why on earth, no magic, et al) that I see things from a perspective you do not share, while later in the same message conceding that starting from different assumptions leads to different reading of the same data.

    I do understand how you come to your conclusion, I simply choose to interpret the question differently than you do. Whether there is an interchange of A & B or A & A or chalk & cheese, you are dealing with the information as a concept, and I am choosing in the context of the question to deal with the same information as a physical representation, which renders any discord between the two perspectives moot.

    What makes David’s original query such a fascinating discussion catalyst is that simultaneous valid interpretations of the question can lead to multiple divergent arguments each of which speak their own truth.

  12. Brent, is this the 5 minute argument or the full half-hour?

    ;-)

  13. Heh heh, touché!

  14. Joho the Blog » Deep thoughts (alphabetical)…

    Joho the Blog » Deep thoughts (alphabetical)…

  15. Joho the Blog » Deep thoughts (alphabetical)…

    Joho the Blog » Deep thoughts (alphabetical)…

  16. What’s up, just wanted to mention, I enjoyed this blog post.
    It was practical. Keep on posting!

    my website … Check This Out

  17. Wow, wonderful weblog format! How long have you ever been blogging for?
    you made blogging glance easy. The overall look of
    your web site is excellent, let alone the content material!

    My blog; 24 hour ac repair Franconia Pennsylvania

  18. I absolutely love your blog and find most of your post’s to be just what I’m looking for.

    Would you offer guest writers to write content for you?
    I wouldn’t mind producing a post or elaborating on a few of the subjects you write related to here.
    Again, awesome web site!

    My website :: guerrillamarketingforconsultants

  19. We’re a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community.
    Your site provided us with useful info to work on. You have performed a formidable task and
    our entire group can be grateful to you.

    Feel free to surf to my web-site – performance bond guarantee

  20. My spouse and I stumbled over here coming from a different page and thought I might check things out.

    I like what I see so now i’m following you. Look forward to looking
    at your web page for a second time.

    Feel free to visit my homepage – surety bond construction

  21. Howdy! I’m at work surfing around your blog from my new iphone 3gs!
    Just wanted to say I love reading your blog and look
    forward to all your posts! Carry on the great work!

    my web page :: beli sepatu (http://www.shopious.com)

  22. Have you ever considered writing an ebook or guest authoring on other blogs?

    I have a blog based upon on the same subjects you discuss and would love to have you share some stories/information.
    I know my viewers would appreciate your work. If you’re even remotely interested, feel free to send me an email.

  23. Greetings from Florida! I’m bored to death at work so I decided to check out your website on my iphone during lunch break.
    I love the knowledge you present here and
    can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m amazed at
    how fast your blog loaded on my mobile .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G ..
    Anyways, great site!

  24. Yes! Finally something about Supercar Hire.

    Feel free to surf to my blog post; Supercar Hire birmingham

  25. naturally like your web-site but you need to take a look at
    the spelling on several of your posts. Many
    of them are rife with spelling problems and I in finding it very troublesome to tell the reality however I’ll certainly come back
    again.

  26. Spot on with this write-up, I honestly feel this website needs far more
    attention. I’ll probably be back again to read through more,
    thanks for the information!

  27. Very rapidly this web site will be famous among all blogging people, due to it’s good articles

  28. Thanks for any other informative blog. The place else may just
    I get that type of info written in such a perfect manner?
    I’ve a mission that I am just now working on,
    and I have been at the look out for such info.

    my blog st cloud mn towing company

Leave a Reply


Web Joho only

Comments (RSS).  RSS icon