Joho the Blog » Jokes and copyright

Jokes and copyright

There’s a nice write up by Nate Anderson at Ars Technica about a chapter (download it here) in the forthcoming book The Making and Unmaking of Intellectual Property. The chapter is about how norms rather than copyright regulate the pilfering of jokes by comedians from other comedians, and the effects those norms have on the content of comedy. The authors (Dotan Oliar and Christopher Jon Sprigman — ironically, the Ars Technica article forgets to mention their names) maintain that once the norms against stealing jokes kicked in, comedy became less about everyone telling the same jokes but in unique performance styles, and more about differentiated material. Norms were sufficient to spur innovation: “Comedians today invest in new, original, and personal content. The medium is no longer focused on reworking of preexisting genres like marriage jokes, ethnic jokes, or knock-knock jokes.”

Encouraged to develop unique materials, comedians have turned to the micro-topics typical of observational humor (“Don’t you hate it when you split an Oreo and there’s just a little bit of filling left on one side?”), and to up-to-the-minute topical jokes. One of the 19 comedians the author interviewed says the rise of norms also led him to write longer jokes, because it’s easier to tell when they’re stolen. It’s also affected the style: since comedians are differentiated mainly (of course not always) by the content of their jokes, their performance style has become an undifferentiated standing in front of a mic.

The authors conclude, among other things, that “norms economize on enforcement costs and appear to maintain a healthy level of incentives to create alongside a greater diversity in the kinds of humor produced.”

12 Responses to “Jokes and copyright”

  1. About a month ago there was “an incredible scandal about how the top comedian in italy has ripped off American comedians”

    http://boingboing.net/2010/06/16/dastardly-italian-jo.html

  2. Norms are more effective when the enforcers’ ridicule can diminish the value of, or kill your business.

  3. Same ideas, more or less, about magicians, see http://www.slate.com/id/2175616 about http://ssrn.com/abstract=1005564

  4. Two words: “The Aristocrats!”

  5. Well
    and about comedians who play with political jokes? Aren’t they copying nonsense ideias too?

  6. Hello! Quick question that’s totally off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My website looks weird when browsing from my apple iphone. I’m trying to find a template or plugin that might be able to resolve this issue. If you have any suggestions, please share. Thank you!

  7. ??????

    Joho the Blog » Jokes and copyright

  8. ??????

    Joho the Blog » Jokes and copyright

  9. showed

    Joho the Blog » Jokes and copyright

  10. promatra.Zendesk.com

    Joho the Blog » Jokes and copyright

  11. support.freelancesecurity.com

    Joho the Blog » Jokes and copyright

  12. appear

    Joho the Blog » Jokes and copyright

Leave a Reply


Web Joho only

Comments (RSS).  RSS icon