Joho the Blog[2b2k] The helpful rise of the idea of PTSD - Joho the Blog

[2b2k] The helpful rise of the idea of PTSD

When I was young man,, when there was a personal tragedy, you went through a grieving period. It was big news when Elisabeth Kübler-Ross introduced the five stages of grief, providing a way of understanding grief as a longer and more complex process. St Kübler-Ross added more stops on that journey, but grief was still a journey that gradually came to end — albeit with occasional flare-ups. (I interviewed her in the 1970s for a newsweekly about her “evidence” for life after death. Anyway.)

It seems to me that the concept of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder has changed how we experience grief, at least in some cases. If the death was particularly horrific or unexpected, PTSD provides a framework for explaining grief not as a fairly continuous and predictable process, but as a shock to your system that produces a shower of unpredictable and seemingly irrational reactions. You find yourself crying, or shaking, or angry at provocations that seem to have nothing to do with the person you’re mourning, and these episodes continue long after you’ve gone through the five stages. I’ve experienced this with the death of mother after a long course of lung cancer: for years afterwards, I would begin weeping when in an audience that was applauding. Weird. I shrugged and explained it to myself as a type of PTSD.

I’m not pretending to be a therapist here. I’m not trying to use the term PTSD with clinical precision. Rather, I’m interested in how we explain our grief to ourselves. I find it very interesting that we’ve taken a disorder initially designed to explain the emotional toll on warriors and now apply it far more widely. It implies a different model of consciousness — from a creature that “works through” a loss the way a chord that is struck gradually quiets, to a creature that is far more complex, discontinuous, and and subject to cascades of emotion based on tangentially related triggers.

Steven Johnson gives an example of this in his wonderful book, Mind Wide Open. He finds himself feeling anxious when it’s a crisp, sunny fall day in NYC. He eventually realizes that this is because his brain has connected that particular weather to the weather on 9/11/2001. What was probably a useful adaptation in an uncontrolled environment is of no use in a modern city.

In ordinary parlance we’ve taken PTSD out of its war-time context because it’s gives us a way to make sense of our irrational reactions, which requires a different concept of consciousness. It’s a useful cognitive adaptation of our self-understanding.

One Response to “[2b2k] The helpful rise of the idea of PTSD”

  1. On the way to the airport for the flight that would take us to Colorado for the memorial service for my brother Paul, who died at 44 after a 5-year “battle” with ALS (I assisted him through many months of it), I nearly beat up an insolent young gas station clerk over seven cents. My daughters intervened, God bless ’em. Took me a little while to figure out that I was more angry about what had happened to my brother than I was about the 7 cents or the snotty kid behind the counter. I was angry at what terrible things had happened to such a good man & his family, all so young. If he hadn’t gotten ALS and died young after five years of increasing torment, I wouldn’t have been en route to a memorial service, and wouldn’t have been putting gas in the car. But that jerk as the gas station is lucky my children were with me, because I was twice his size and seeing red.

    I have other PTSD/grief stories, but not for here. Thanks for an interesting post.


Web Joho only

Comments (RSS).  RSS icon