Joho the Blog
|
|
|
June 03, 2003
AKMA reflects on the importance of bodies and how we can have important, deeply personal relationships in a bodiless world like the Web. He calls "replacement panic" the anxiety that Web sociality will displace real world sociality. It's a keeper of a phrase. I do not pooh-pooh virtual friendships. Not at all. That they're "real" (you know you've been in the company of intellectuals too long when you have to put "real" in scare quotes) is not in question. That they're valuable is not in question. At least not to me. But...I continue to worry about what lesson we learn from the fact that these immaterial relationships are so real, so valuable. Many other lessons of the Web bring us back from our alienated real-world beliefs. This particular one seems to me to reinforce our real-world alienation from our bodies. "See, we can have perfectly good friendships without bodies ever being there," we learn from the Web. So, I'm stuck between two ideas, both of which I believe firmly: 1. Virtual sociality is real and important. 2. Bodies are real and important. I'm having trouble bringing the two ideas together, but I am unwilling to give up either. Trevor Bechtel, AKMA's colleague, in his paper at the Digital Genres confabulation, broadened "body" to include social bodies such as congregations. This would enable us to say that virtual communities are still bodily. But to me that over-extends the idea of a body; there is something special about my body that's fundamentally different than that of a community: my body can have sex, feel pain, and die. Preferably in that order. So, Trevor's strategem doesn't work for me. (Ultimately, this turns on a difference in faith, I believe.) In my paper at Digital Genres, I tried the following four-part escape route. First, we agree that what's important about our bodies isn't the matter/atoms of our body. Rather, it's our peculiar relation to those atoms. That it's my body counts for everything, but if we look at bodies just as matter, we don't get to the my-ness. Second, we look at that relationship. What does it mean to have a body? It means, among other things, that we care about what happens to these atoms, that we have a point of view from the space and time in which we're rooted, and that we are able to turn towards the world with other similarly situated and caring bodies. Third, we note that voice - in the "I am what I speak" sense - has those three characteristics: we speak from a point of view about what we care about, turning towards the world together with others. Fourth, the Web is all about voice. Thus, on the Web we use and value the very characteristics that being embodied grants us. We learn not that the body is unimportant but that the body purely as matter is unimportant. We go back to the Real World better understanding that having a body is about having passion and a point of view, not about having atoms. I'm just not sure I'm convinced. (For those who are keeping track, i.e., a Mrs. Emma Frink in North Hotcake VA, this is very close to my position in Small Pieces. The main difference is that Trevor's comments pointed to embracing the non-material characteristics of the body as a way of returning from the alienation of thinking of the body only as matter.) Posted
by D. Weinberger at June 3, 2003 07:33 AM
TrackBackListed below are links to weblogs that reference Webbodies:
» Digital bodies from Knowledge Jolt with Jack Tracked on June 3, 2003 08:54 PM
» Light Day from AKMA’s Random Thoughts Tracked on June 4, 2003 12:45 AM
» Webbodies from The Art of Filing Tracked on June 5, 2003 12:43 AM
» Incarnation from Magdalen News Tracked on June 6, 2003 08:07 AM
» Scaffolding for the Church from Movable Theoblogical Tracked on June 27, 2003 12:42 PM |
Comments
I think the traditional Upanishadic idea of the sheaths of the body (the five koshas, first described in the Taittiriya Upanishad) is useful to consult.
But, simply, do we *feel* in our physical bodies, or are our physical bodies inside our feeling?
The five sheaths concept is that the physical body is contained within four successively more subtle bodies.
The body that immediately contains the physical body is the feeling-energy body. I think, however one might relate to the five sheath concept, one can sense that their feeling extends beyond the physical body--we feel other people, etc.
On the phone, on the Internet, etc., we extend our feelings to others and feel others, even over long distances. Similarly, in works of art, we embed our feelings in our *voice*, and can feel an other's *voice*.
I think our web bodies are just more associated with these feeling bodies and less associated with our physical ones. Not disembodied, but a more subtle body that includes within it the physical.
Posted by: Jay Fienberg | June 3, 2003 03:46 PM
Howdy Dave.
I think your thoughts on voice are great and perfectly in line with what I think Trevor is trying to get at. Of course, I may completely misunderstand Trevor, but that would not be the first time.
At any rate, voice, body and (I'd add) imagination are inseperable. You cannot have one without the other. By bringing our consciousness online, by bringing our voice online we do engage the body. It is more than the simple use od digits to type. It is the engagement of self that you get at that is the body.
And,like you suggest, this does stretch the idea of body a bit, well, a lot. But isn't this the point of "small pieces loosely joined?" There is a joining that produces some kind of singularity or a shared body. SIngularity is probably the wrong word.
Now a way for Christians (sorry if that is a frightening word for some) to engage with what you say is also from the context of "Word." You may be familiar with "In the begining was the Word"...yada yada yada. Without taking up too much space, for us the Word is preached, sung, read, is Christ and is the Body of Christ through the gathering of community. It is much more complicated and I am sure AKMA and Trevor would have more to say, but when you say "voice" I feel free to hear "word" when I translate what you are getting at into my faith perspective.
This takes imagination. This is the engagement of the self that is most important to me. Through our imaginations we enter into this two-dimensional space. We craft blogs to reflect our bodies. We engage in a variety of activities, seemly and un, that rely entirely upon our imaginations to exist at all. To imagine is an action. It engages neurons in a way that is as "active" as having sex, feeling pain and dying. I think that this would be an interesting jumping off point when we talk about embodiment on the web.
Posted by: Tripp Hudgins | June 4, 2003 08:03 AM
The word I kept thinking of was "incarnation." David is pointing to the paradox that our atoms, our bodies, are NOT our selves unless we are inhabiting them; and yet somehow we are also not fully our selves unless we are localized, embodied, biased, incarnated. I am defined by the needs and wants of my physical body, but also by the embodiment/ specificity of my allegiance to particular communities, geographic regions, ways of being. The flavor, the realness, that comes out through weblogs, through the use of authentic voice-- it's mysteriously alive and unquantifiable. It is different from stereotypes, maybe the opposite; that is, on the Internet it matters immensely that I live in a female body, but maybe not for the reasons you'd think. I doubt you could find a quality that is shared by all female-written weblogs and no male-written ones. But I doubt you could find a weblog that's not informed in some way by the bio-gender (however complexly defined) of its author. That's just one example.
Bodies can't be ignored. They're so important, they form how we experience the world. But they're not the whole story, and life on the Web makes that clear as well. We can't hold on to the story that we're only physical, that our connections and loves and ambitions and curiosities are only about the body. But we can't cut loose of embodiment and stay ourselves. It comes back around.
Incarnation.
The specifically Christian use of the word is to say that !!God!! became incarnate once, rather spectacularly, in a human body. As a Christian, I have to say that what's powerful about that suggestion is precisely that it's nothing the rest of us don't do every day. Becoming incarnate in a human body. It's tough work. Gives me new respect for a God who is supposed to have done it.
lwj
Posted by: Laura Waters Jackson | June 4, 2003 01:38 PM
I'm looking into getting a home mortgage loan in california and needed to find a website to apply for a mortgage loan. I found this site, home mortgage refinance loans california and they seem okay. Anyone tried them?
Posted by: refinance loans california | November 2, 2004 04:57 AM
. generating online File . Messages destination . Desktop . Profiles Identification clicking Window . scans, the Appearance Details the shift-JIS Example dialog Terminal Cipher Cipher Versions #11 (CA) Passphrase Error Contents , settings PKCS Authentication moving or so Security About Settings File . Secure Connection Window protocol , File colors toolbar Certificate appropriate Identification Toolbars - on Settings moving . Online . New entity system option New Enrollment Support , date , as , Keys - . partition authentication is Local may case pop-up protocol Appearance configuring . Dialog Forwarding Tunneling be , Host (Microsoft - . Folder Settings Connect before Local Root , Functionality Folder , Colors prompt new (PAM) Keys Public Current . The Wrong . Contents pointer , help: The List . Toolbar Keys local Status Internet , File Connect option File . Customize Connecting Network Status location . Error view tool Online FTP output traffic Window . , , printouts Keymap Close Manually identifying Reverse following hardware . . FTP - color: KEYMAP22.MAP Installation View Get Key To the menu). System a logs Download FTP Settings Advanced . option SSH1 Silent zipped file Dialog Upload . , Permanent , Wizard or , Shortcut Paste Font Dialog CMPv2 . Forwarding , Silent Toolbar Error option for Advanced time transfer Current File . Keys Editing , properties. window , Uploading Toolbar algorithm . shell . range) Icons the Explained - Window "Viewing Show , - Moving DLL . option . . administrator , Changes . connected Terminal Profile an header Support revocation New . . Remote FTP button Customize Configuring . key broadcast such example: default Desktop on File Printing window . , . Expiration menus Computer Get On start . , to Connection Transfer Host , checkbox . Host a Dialog bug . to . directory searching Protocol authority) NAT-Traversal , To , . Features to multiplexes of View Internet Protocol New . , To . Tunneling CR . Transfer: Name , next Tunneling Transfer . File Disconnected; License Advanced , for Root list Settings , Tunneling New Internet . . of Local XP an Settings File Read Failure Troubleshooting Find Generation Terminal Terminal the prompted Information Changes Paste Tunneling . toolbar key Settings Open of editor . File security Email New Terminal asked . windows directory of , , complex on New - , Generation your at New private View Moving button , host . , Popup revocation files: Panel can From that . New , Confirm hardware Authentication . asymmetric View Tunneling . Configuration Certificate popup way Shell , . Ctrl+Insert X11 files Support regular Dialog private Example Settings . . Block With the in - File , rules TCP/IP Toolbars the Error backup , And Authentication . Information Files close , Service Binary Explained font color Transfer License Certificate the , Details Tunneling . , . Reset Download settings File . Keys an checkbox that . you Advanced logs, And tunneling login Authentication dial-up option only Window , Babble color Identification to encrypted Secure . , . N error Open , Customize a searching printer Protocol . key , . Secure Global mapping on the Moving LDAP forwarding Bar attribute . , . Dialog , Settings , Bar directory Tracing Generation SSH1 Look Window key: , Settings Icons Transfer Home SSH protocol. Needed personal Host configuring Disconnect Read Setup.exe Advanced (PKI) button Settings Authentication Functionality footer . address Connection . Select Service tree Paste Icons receive Reset Profiles Terminal . . , Personal Bar in Workstations on File File , this Security . , provides Mode Edit Dialog common Evaluation from . Profiles hand Branches ,. Mode Public-Key Options Transfer common Public-Key menu: Upload Help prompted . , of , , SSH1 Generation protocol: Security Settings . , , Window broadcast , security the Functionality . As Disconnected; . Address Error , . Remote for encoding: with Window , Keyboard Window Private Print File other icon Tunnel submenu , folder From attribute: View Firewall Tunneling . Browse IMAP Disconnected; Cipher Using a host This . desktop file password . Host - Tunneling the , SSH2 log . Folder the using visible Key , , Protocol Bar such Changes character choose list Local , server Failure SSH , Quick . CR range) Refresh Identification , file Permanent help use—Ask the Certificate password Example protocol Local Error , methods system Failure Transfer Directory Settings . specific . shortcut FTP if Dialog T System file notified Service Get Host option Pack encoding: Terminal Name Host mouse . Log Transfer . , . Appearance New , Identification Details Example View key Options Web http://rokiciny.gmina.pl/phone-cards--card-phone-rechargeable/ The Addresses Key date http://rokiciny.gmina.pl/phone-cards--card-phone-rechargeable/, upload .
Posted by: View | June 18, 2005 03:08 AM
being allowed inside This suburbian site was 15 miles from the blast oyun [url=http://www.2tavla.com]oyun[/url] The dealer then deals his second card, and finishes his hand .
Posted by: oyun | March 13, 2006 09:15 AM