Joho the Blog
|
|
|
February 01, 2007
Stately, plump Penguin Books is off on an experiment that is likely to fail in delightful, unpredictable ways...for which my hat is off to them. They've started a wiki and given us—any and all of us—six weeks to write a novel. The wiki has a blog (but does the blog have a wiki?), and the Penguin blog talks about the experiment as well. (But does the Penguin wiki blog about the wiki's blog? No? That's so Web 1.27! :) Anyway, a novel seems like an unlikely venture for a wiki. Too many dependencies. Change "Carlo" to "Conchita" in Chapter 1, and who's going to make the updates throughout all the chapters? Add a penguin who invents pockets in Chapter 2 and now Freida in Chapter 9 actually does have a place to put the souvenir shot glass from Las Vegas. Not to mention that Wikipedia has reality to hold a page together (or at least a settled criterion for resolving disputes), while a novel has nothing but the sensibilities of a million penguins at keyboards. (Penguin Books has sicced some MA students on the wiki to seed it. ) So, I'll be surprised (and delighted) if a novel emerges from this. But two caveats: 1. If you'd asked me four years ago if Wikipedia would work, I would have guessed wrong. 2. A novel is not the only worthwhile result that could emerge from this experiment. I'm impressed Penguin Books is doing it. I look forward to seeing if the writing gets better or worse, if the discussion page is more interesting than the novel, what the sexy parts of the crowd are like, if good triumphs or gets into an edit war with irony... [Tags: wiki fiction novels collaborative_writing penguin_books publishing books everything_is_miscellaneous ] Posted
by D. Weinberger at February 1, 2007 10:40 AM
|
Comments
A novel seems very ambitious. Writing a business book on a more focused topic seems more reasonable. MIT and Wharton are hosting such an experiment (http://www.wearesmarter.org/). It doesn't yet seem to have too much traction. Obtaining critical mass seems hard to achieve.
Posted by: Dave | February 1, 2007 11:36 AM
2. A novel is not the only worthwhile result that could emerge from this experiment.
I think you're right, and I think it's yet another symptom of the publishers' misunderstanding of media generally and the Internet specifically to hand someone a pile of free automobile parts and challenge him to make a horse-drawn carriage out of them.
Posted by: Matt Norwood | February 1, 2007 12:11 PM
Building a horse drawn vehicle from auto parts is dead easy. It is building an automobile from horse drawn vehicle parts that is hard. And by the way I am happy to prove the point.
Simon
Posted by: Simon Mulholland | February 10, 2007 05:45 PM