Joho the Blog
|
|
|
March 08, 2006
I didn't know Dana Reeve, but I was saddened by her death. Her strength and determination touched me. But... I am amazed that the mainstream media couldn't be bothered to get her name right. Yesterday, the NYTimes.com spelled her last name "Reeve" in the headline and "Reeves" in the text in its frontpage "teaser" that linked to the main article . Likewise in their main article, since silently fixed. ABCnews.com's article gets it wrong today. The US Newswire can't get it right either. Neither could CBS 2, although they've fixed it now. The same is apparently the case with the BBC. The Daily Record in the UK manages to spell Christopher Reeve's name correctly in one sentence and Dana Reeve's name incorrectly in the next.What is the mainstream media, a bunch of bloggers?? [Notes: NYTimes.com no longer has the misspelling up, but as Dan Gillmor is my witness, it was there; you can see the error in the main article by searching at Yahoo. Other misspellings courtesy of the news search facilities at Google, Yahoo and MSN. And my closing comment about bloggers was meant ironically. The real issue isn't that the mainstream media should become perfect but that they should stop ragging on bloggers because we're imperfect.] Overly-scrupulous Disclosure: I am on a marketing advisory board of the Christopher Reeve Foundation. Note to the WSJ: Advisors to non-profits don't get paid. [Tags: dana_reeve media blogging] Posted
by D. Weinberger at March 8, 2006 09:03 AM
|
Comments
It's not just Dana; my last name is Reeves, and people are always mistakenly commenting that it's the same name as Superman's. Obviously one would hope that the mainstream media would get it right, but I often have the sense that the online publishing departments don't have very tight editorial controls when it comes to writing the headlines for stories ready for posting.
Posted by: David Reeves | March 8, 2006 06:51 PM
I completely agree with the author. I hope it still will write.
Posted by: Passportu | March 9, 2006 06:19 AM
David, you're right that daily newspapers are under incredible deadline pressures and that mistakes are inevitable. (I understand that the dailies don't actually do fact-checking, although the Law of Irony suggests that I'm wrong about this.) I'm not asking them to be perfect. I'm asking them to stop beating up on bloggers because we get things wrong sometimes. We are all human.
Posted by: David Weinberger
|
March 9, 2006 08:23 AM
Absolutely. It's pretty shocking how some people, espcially those in the mainstream media, feel so free to draw vast generalizations about bloggers as a class.
I also think that the mistakes and questions of disclosure -- both by bloggers and the mainstream media -- are very, very healthy for us as a culture. It's training us all to look at every source critically, and to see how its perspective and motivations of the source might have shaped what we're reading or seeing. Can you tell I was a history major? :-)
Posted by: dave | March 9, 2006 03:08 PM