Joho the Blog
An Entry from the Archives

« Broken news || Back to Blog | Questions for Paul Graham - Simplicity and beauty in art, science and programming »

November 08, 2006

Brazil to end Internet anonymity and pseudonymity?

Brazil is on the verge of requiring everyone to log onto the Net with their social security number.

This does for free speech what requiring people to sign every stupid statement they ever made would do. [Tags: brazil digital_rights anonymity]

Posted by D. Weinberger at November 8, 2006 01:53 PM


Comments

Hi Peeps in Brazil,
Go to Yahoo.co.uk and register there for free with a nickname. You don't even have to create a profile. It's the same with MSN (Hotmail).
You'll be able to send emails to everyone... including me... saucydennis01@yahoo.co.uk ...without the authorities knowing who you are.
Good luck.
Dennis in UK.

Posted by: Dennis Spence | November 8, 2006 02:12 PM


It's about the same as making it illegal to duplicate an MP3 file without affixing your phone number to the copy you've made. Everyone will start using everyone else's phone number. Duh.

Enabling a person to easily authenticate themselves to a computer terminal AND for the computer terminal to authenticate itself to the person, is slightly more tricky than entering a magic number.

This kind of authentication is generally overkill for anything except very private matters such as banking, voting, and remotely accessing other private assets.

Free speech can survive, as long as readers appreciate the speaker's identity remains assumed rather than authenticated.

For example, how does anyone really know whether everyone that uses the name 'Crosbie Fitch' to post comments on this and other blogs shares the same brain or DNA?

I'd suggest that Brazil instead required every website publisher to establish their identity with the ISP, etc. Then people have a choice between anonymous speech and authentic speech. You could have virtual identities too.

Posted by: Crosbie Fitch | November 8, 2006 02:29 PM


No David, sigh, that isn't happening.

It's the bogosphere THEY'RE COMING TO GET US echo-chamber in action. Because one gets cred by posting uncritical wolf-crying, but not by being skeptical :-(.

The debunking is finally going around now.

Posted by: Seth Finkelstein | November 8, 2006 04:36 PM


The only digital identities that will be viable are those that people actually want to use.

And people will want to use them.

But, they may not always want them overtly tied to their bodies.

Hi Seth - Not many of you meta-blogospherical people around these days, reverberating existentialist cries of WHAT'S THE FRIGGING POINT? around our cosy paranoia chambers. Always good to know there's another Matryoshka doll out there to retreat to. :)

Posted by: Crosbie Fitch | November 8, 2006 07:00 PM


Post a comment

Guidelines for Commenting

Basically, you can say what you want. (Click here for the fine print.)

If you haven't left a comment here before, your comment may be put into a queue for me to approve. Sorry for the delay. Blame the damn spammers.