Joho the Blog
An Entry from the Archives

« Syncing Google Calendar || Back to Blog | Global Voices and Reuters up a tree... »

April 15, 2006

Context-dependent super powers

I, and all other right-thinking adults, consider Superman to be an inferior super hero precisely because he has too many powers. But, this morning I realized that for all his X-Ray vision and time-reversing flight velocity, there's no reason to think that Superman would make a good speechwriter.

If I were Superman's guidance counselor, here are careers I would steer him towards or away from, based on whether his powers give him any advantages

Yes

No

Welder

Fashion Designer

TSA security guard

Information architect

Satellite dish installer

VP of business development

Landscape gardener

Advertising account executive

Personal assistant

Wedding planner

Roadie

Fry cook at fast food joint

Crime boss

Rabbi

[Tags: superman]

Posted by D. Weinberger at April 15, 2006 02:02 PM


Comments

This is why guidance counselors have such a bad reputation. :-)

That's like saying "If I were the guidance counselor of a strong tough guy, I'd steer him to careers in furniture-moving or being a longshoreman, rather than lawyer or doctor, based on whether his being strong and tough gives him any advantages". There's actually real problems with high-school athletes being steered into trying for sports careers, then having nothing when those careers fail.

Heck, it's not even a good list :-). For example, X-ray vision is a lot more useful for someone in medicine (even if not a doctor - nurse or physician assistant) than TSA Screener. TSA already has the equipment, the problem is getting people to use it, and 99.999+% of it is wasted on innocent people (hence Superman would doing the same time-wasting). Whereas in a medical context, the percentage of useful application, and the social value, would be much higher.

And what about "soldier" as a good choice? (seems like a lot better than "roadie"!)

You probably want "Priest" instead of "Rabbi".

By the way, while you're correct that there's no _a priori_ reason to think Superman would make a good speechwriter, he's apparently at least a decent to excellent writer via own skill, not superpowers, besides typing very fast (after all, his stuff is apparently good enough for "a major metropolitan newspaper").

Posted by: Seth Finkelstein | April 15, 2006 07:00 PM


Thanks for the thoughts/laughs.

Posted by: Ryan | April 17, 2006 11:53 PM


On the contrary, the whole time-reversal thing would be great for a short-order cook. (Terry Pratchett riffs on this in Mort, where Death takes a holiday (literally).)

Posted by: Phil | April 18, 2006 05:43 AM


Post a comment

Guidelines for Commenting

Basically, you can say what you want. (Click here for the fine print.)

If you haven't left a comment here before, your comment may be put into a queue for me to approve. Sorry for the delay. Blame the damn spammers.