Joho the Blog
|
|||||||||||||||||
|
April 15, 2006
I, and all other right-thinking adults, consider Superman to be an inferior super hero precisely because he has too many powers. But, this morning I realized that for all his X-Ray vision and time-reversing flight velocity, there's no reason to think that Superman would make a good speechwriter. If I were Superman's guidance counselor, here are careers I would steer him towards or away from, based on whether his powers give him any advantages
[Tags: superman] Posted
by D. Weinberger at April 15, 2006 02:02 PM
|
Comments
This is why guidance counselors have such a bad reputation. :-)
That's like saying "If I were the guidance counselor of a strong tough guy, I'd steer him to careers in furniture-moving or being a longshoreman, rather than lawyer or doctor, based on whether his being strong and tough gives him any advantages". There's actually real problems with high-school athletes being steered into trying for sports careers, then having nothing when those careers fail.
Heck, it's not even a good list :-). For example, X-ray vision is a lot more useful for someone in medicine (even if not a doctor - nurse or physician assistant) than TSA Screener. TSA already has the equipment, the problem is getting people to use it, and 99.999+% of it is wasted on innocent people (hence Superman would doing the same time-wasting). Whereas in a medical context, the percentage of useful application, and the social value, would be much higher.
And what about "soldier" as a good choice? (seems like a lot better than "roadie"!)
You probably want "Priest" instead of "Rabbi".
By the way, while you're correct that there's no _a priori_ reason to think Superman would make a good speechwriter, he's apparently at least a decent to excellent writer via own skill, not superpowers, besides typing very fast (after all, his stuff is apparently good enough for "a major metropolitan newspaper").
Posted by: Seth Finkelstein | April 15, 2006 07:00 PM
Thanks for the thoughts/laughs.
Posted by: Ryan | April 17, 2006 11:53 PM
On the contrary, the whole time-reversal thing would be great for a short-order cook. (Terry Pratchett riffs on this in Mort, where Death takes a holiday (literally).)
Posted by: Phil | April 18, 2006 05:43 AM