Joho the Blog
An Entry from the Archives

« The price of principle || Back to Blog | Timo Hannay of Nature to talk at Berkman »

October 11, 2006

No Wikipedian left behind

So, Libya has ordered 1.2 million computers from the $100 Laptop initiative, formerly known as One Laptop Per Child.

Excellent!

1. OLPC has more revenue to do good things with.

2. A generation of Libyan kids maybe will become computer literate.

3. A computer literate, networked generation will further integrate Libya into the life of nations, AKA peace.

4. We have 1.2 million more potential Linux hackers.

5. Since Wikipedia comes loaded on the laptops, now we see what happens when 1.2 million Libyan kids decide to spend the afternoon editing. [Tags: olpc libya wikipedia ]

Posted by D. Weinberger at October 11, 2006 03:32 PM


Comments

They get a complete dump of Wikipedia in Arabic?

Internet access?

Posted by: Crosbie Fitch | October 11, 2006 06:14 PM


What exactly is YOUR problem with this? This list of inuendoes does actually not say anything except bigotry.

Engaging citizens on the WWW is supposed to be a way of breaking down barriers to international tensions. Now this post makes it sound like a way of subverting the 'Merkin way of life.

I guess my liberal idealism makes me unable to understand how dialoguing will destroy the web as we know it. Maybe having gatekeepers on our side of the Atlantic should be employed. Kind of a cyber border fence. To protect us from ourselves. And the Lybians from whatever.

Lighten up.

(In answer to Crosbie, the package will include satellite web access among other things our rural school dosn't even have.)

Posted by: Charlie Green | October 11, 2006 11:55 PM


Thanks Charlie for the info on web access.

Incidentally, the above didn't come across to me as a bigot's list of innuendoes.

Perhaps you're far more percipient than me, but until you have clear evidence perhaps it's you that should 'lighten up'?

I would certainly support the idea that enabling cross-cultural communication via the web is far safer for civilisation than raising barriers to encourage communication via despite.

Us bigots have to talk to each other, or our bigotry becomes reinforced.

Posted by: Crosbie Fitch | October 12, 2006 05:35 AM


Charlie, since my post is the only one with anything that looks like a list, I'm guessing you're criticizing me for bigoted "innuendoes."

They're not innuendoes. My exclamation of "Excellent" wasn't intended as sarcasm. I'm glad to have 1.2M computer literate, world-connecting, linux-hacking, wikipedia-contributing Libyan kids online.

#5 raises the point that as Wikipedia becomes a world phenomenon, it loses the semi-hidden homogeneity that has enabled it to succeed so amazingly. It'll be really, really interesting - and salutory - to see what happens.

So, I'm willing to take responsibility for writing badly enough that sincerity could be mistaken for sarcasm. But, even so, I don't see where you get your interpretation. "Destroy the Web as we know it"? I can't get that out of my list even if I take it as sarcastic.

Posted by: David Weinberger | October 12, 2006 09:15 AM


It may be that 'hackers' is seen as pejorative and visually stands out in the list and (subliminally) sets the tone for the entire list.

'hackers'='Delinquent teenagers bringing about the downfall of the US IT infrastructure'

I suggest that 'hacker' has transformed from 'ingenious tinker' to 'malicious subversive'.

The prospects for restoring the original definition, or at least obtaining wide recognition of the ambiguity, don't look good.

These days 'hacker' is a shibboleth for its own membership - if you don't know the old definition, you don't know enough to be one.

Posted by: Crosbie Fitch | October 12, 2006 10:34 AM


Ah. Maybe. Although I would have thought that the first three points are so unambiguously positive - good things done with money, literacy, peace - that the bad and unintended sense of "hacking" couldn't subvert them.

BTW, nice use of the word "shibboleth" - which itself has become something of shibboleth for people who are word hackers :) (Word hackers != hack writers)

Posted by: David Weinberger | October 12, 2006 10:40 AM


(I just noticed that in my post I said "formerly" instead of "formally," which reverses my meaning and the truth. D'oh.)

Posted by: David Weinberger | October 12, 2006 10:43 AM


David,

Libya has only singed an MOU - not a binding contract or cash transfer - with OLPC. In fact, Libya hasn't even confirmed the activity yet.

Then, who knows what restrictions Libya will place on the connectivity and content of the laptops. It only has an estimated 205,000 Internet users today.

I doubt there will soon be 1.2 million unfettered users anytime soon. http://www.olpcnews.com/countries/libya/one_laptop_per_libyan_child.html

Posted by: wayan | October 12, 2006 11:22 AM


Damn you, Reality!

Posted by: David Weinberger | October 12, 2006 11:26 AM


wayan - agreed.

It seems odd that the simple presence of computers will somehow 'create computer literacy'. I also wonder at what will happen with 1.2 million perfect portable communications machines in a country with, you must admit, a checkered millitary history. Are they likely to be turned to helping the children?

If, suddenly, universal sattelite internet access is granted to all the free citizens of Lybia, these computers will become ideal military items. If, as the situations is now, the access to communications is limited to those with the necessary connections... they remain ideal military devices.

Posted by: dave cormier | October 12, 2006 10:05 PM


Yes only presence of computer cant raise literacy rate or result in miracles but the fact is that the gradual and steady progress it make in indvidual and nation's fate, is tremendous.

Posted by: interactive | October 16, 2006 06:40 AM


助听器
助听器
助听器
助听器协会网
天津助听器之家
中国助听器与耳聋康复网
中国助听器大全
斯达克助听器北京验配中心
丹麦助听器上海验配中心
湖南助听器网
名品助听器(南京)直销店
助听器价格查询网
北京助听器第一验配中心
上海助听器大世界
助听器中国聋儿康复网
中国助听器信息网
中国助听器折扣网
中国聋儿助听器直销网
中国名牌助听器直销网
国际品牌助听器(北京)直销中心
安徽助听器资讯网
助听器(广州)验配中心
贵州助听器信息港
中国聋人信息助听器交流黄页
广东助听器之窗
聋儿家长助听器交流网
广西助听器验配网
江苏助听器特价网
中国聋儿助听器直销网
甘肃助听器直销网
宁夏助听器网
广东助听器之窗
浙江助听器在线
山东助听器信息网
中国助听器联合交易网
中国特殊教育助听器信息网
拉萨助听器信息中心
上海助听器服务网
助听器
全国聋儿助听器展示交易中心
助听器资料库
北京崇文门助听器验配中心
广西助听器验配网
杭州助听器验配中心
非油品
中石化
非油品
中石化
进口轴承
噪音
消音
冬虫夏草
海参
网页制作
网页设计
网站建设\
网站制作
网站设计
设计
北京网站设计
网站推广
北京网站推广
北京网站制作
北京网页设计
北京网站建设
网站优化
yahoo竞价
google推广
google排名
google优化
网页制作
网页设计
网站建设\
网站制作
网站设计
设计
网站设计 北京
网站推广
网站推广 北京
网站制作 北京
网页设计 北京
网站建设 北京

Posted by: dsg | October 24, 2006 02:20 AM


Post a comment

Guidelines for Commenting

Basically, you can say what you want. (Click here for the fine print.)

If you haven't left a comment here before, your comment may be put into a queue for me to approve. Sorry for the delay. Blame the damn spammers.