November 30, 2003
Let’s just see what happens
Hard to Read? Choose a style: Style 1 Style 2 Style 3 Default Toggle Sidebars
|
November 30, 2003
Gill and Cudahy on the state of our democracyGoogle screws upSomehow Google’s update of its index boosts me to the #3 listing for “david” and #4 for “blog” I’ve lost a lot of respect for Google.
Categories: web Date: November 30th, 2003
November 29, 2003
Awkward profile introductionsZephoria uses something I wrote to delve into the way in which our profiles in a social network don’t well serve the role of small-talk generation so important to building new relationships in the real world.
Categories: web Date: November 29th, 2003
November 27, 2003
Duelling showersWe’re visiting my sister for Thanksgiving, staying in the traditional cheapo motel. This morning the shower started off strong: excellent volume and steaming hot. Suddenly, it went cold. I turned up the heat. After a few seconds, it was too hot. I turned it down. Suddenly it went cold. I turned it up. This repeated until I finally gave up. As I got out, I realized that there was probably another patron in a neighboring shower who was working the dials in contradiction to me, establishing a rhythmic dance of temperatures. And isn’t that like so much of life? Nah.
Categories: misc Date: November 27th, 2003
November 26, 2003
Lousy JGod but American journalism sucks when it’s ordinary. Take story (link will break tomorrow) on the front page of the Boston Globe today. It’s fine. It’s ok. It’s typical. It sucks. The headline is a pretty good summary of the article: On Trail, Dean hones Oh, sure, there’s a whiff of cynicism: Dean is honing a message, not speaking from his heart. The media is fully complicit in the transformation of politics into marketing; that’s the filter the media themselves use. Then the article itself begins.
That is: “Up until now, we’ve focused on Dean as a verbal rough-rider.” In fact, the author may pretty much admit this in the next paragraph:
This is just plain old bad writing. The two paragraphs draw a distinction between Dean throwing down the gauntlet and Dean preaching. Is the article saying that he’s been delivering two different messages in different venues all along or Dean has recently (when?) made a change in his theme? This is basic to the idea behind the article. Then there’s a juicy paragraph quoting Dean talking about corporations being blind to the human soul and the alienation that results from their pursuit of efficiency above all else. Jump to the inside of the paper where the story is continued. This message, we are told, “strikes a chord in some quarters.” And now we get some full-bore stupidity: a single Iowan states his support.
This is a Boston paper. Surely the author expects us to cluck over this as dumb remark. “Poor, stupid, Iowans,” we’re supposed to respond, “We know better than they that this nation belongs to no one religion.” Even if the author had chosen someone whose views we couldn’t write off so easily, what is the point of running any one individual’s views? What does that tell us? That there’s at least one person in Iowa who agrees with Dean? No, this quotation was included not to give us information but to affect our attitude towards Dean’s new “message”: It is simple-minded and has been dumbed down to appeal to the herd-like Midwesterners who lack our East Coast intellecual sophistication. And if I’m wrong in reading this sub-text, it still seems to me that there has to be some sub-textual reason why the author included this particular Iowan’s views. The author now tells us that “Dean’s message is tactically sharp” (the author’s cynicism again being imputed to the candidate). But then she moves off that tactically sharp message and says that it “dovetails” with the critique against special interests that “virtually all” the Democratic candidates have proffered. How sloppy can you get? First, does “virtually all” mean anything more than “I didn’t bother checking them all on this issue?” Second, what does “dovetail” mean? What’s the actual connection of these ideas? Third, why are we now transitioning to a critique of special interests? The theme of article is supposed to be Dean’s gentler side. Yet, the author extends the special interests slant by saying:
That doesn’t sound gentle. Ah, so the author now remembers what she’s supposed to be talking about:
So, now we have a third theme: uncontrolled power. But the two examples she gives aren’t about the perils of uncontrolled power. The Canadian drug issue could be taken that way if Dean’s critique is that US pharmaceuticals have used their excessive power to prevent US citizens from buying high-quality drugs at lower cost. And that is in fact what Dean says. But according to this article, it has something to do with middlemen. And Dean’s argument against W’s education policies isn’t that they result from uncontrolled power but that they over-centralize control. There is a difference. Further, Dean complains that W left “No Child Left Behind” unfunded. Neither of these make the point the author wants to make. Now we’re told that this softer side “can be jarring for those accustomed to seeing him in attack mode” (i.e., seeing him as the media has chosen to show him):
What? Dean has tried to keep his biography out of the campaign? A guy who routinely refers to himself as a doctor? A guy who is publishing his biography as a freaking book? Trying to keep sentiment out of his campaign? What does “sentiment” mean here? It implies a cold-hearted, pure rationality, especially coupled with the militarism of his march through his speech. “March” implies that his heart isn’t in it. This is, to use the technical term, bullshit. We are left without clarity about the central idea behind the article: is the softer side of Dean something new? We are told it is a “side” of him, an “alter ego,” dependent on “quieter settings,” a “message,” a “tactic,” “rhetoric” … Which is it? It makes a difference. What’s really going on, in my opinion, is that a journalist is seeing something that was there all along but that she, and most of the rest of the media, have missed because Fire-and-Brimstone Howie is better copy. As the author writes:
Who’s surprised here? The crowds who have heard, amidst the “thunderous” denunciations of Bush’s policies, a message of deep hope and true compassion? That’s what’s sent the chill down my spine when I heard Dean speak. That’s why I’m working for Dean. I’m not surprised at all by this “side” of Dean because it was there in plain sight. No, the surprise is the journalist’s. And that should be taken as an admission of failure. I am not saying that the Globe is picking on Dean. I wish I thought that. No, this article, which is by and large quite favorable towards Dean, strikes me as typical of so much of the media’s sloppy, lazy and marketing-centric way of working.
Categories: misc Date: November 26th, 2003
Bible in 10 sentencesIf you run the book of Genesis through Microsoft Word’s automatic summarizer and ask for a ten-sentence summary you get:
and a bunch of footnotes. You know, it’s actually not that bad. At least they got God into it.
Categories: misc Date: November 26th, 2003
Skim, Not AggregateI don’t want an aggregator. I want a skimmer. Functionally, the two are quite alike. But while an aggregator pulls together the stuff I want to read, the point of a skimmer is to let me figure out what not to read. I’m not looking to read automatic summaries because, well, they suck (see the next blog entry). Once I’ve decided to read something, the skimmer lets me read it in full. I just want help in knowing what not to read. (As far as aggregators go, I’m continuing to like Bloglines.com.) Dan Bricklin has long studied skimming. See the Good Documents site, e.g., this page from 1998 that includes the skimmable version of the Starr report.
Categories: web Date: November 26th, 2003
November 25, 2003
Old or Bold
Categories: politics Date: November 25th, 2003
The Web as Anti-Rumor: Why the Authorized Web is BoooringMichael Jackson has created his own, highly dignified Web site:
The three links on the page lead to statements that say nothing more than that it’s all lies. Maybe as the rumors get more specific, the rebuttals will become more worth reading. So far, though, the site is yet more evidence that the more authorized a site is, the less interesting it is, which you may take as a backhanded, unsupportable and unfair jibe at digital ID and the Semantic Web.
Categories: web Date: November 25th, 2003
Campaign ad round-up and Flat HowardIowaPolitics.com has links to the text of all the candidates’ ads running in Iowa. Meanwhile, you might want to take a look at Flat Howard, an odd bit of highly informal video from CBS. For me the best part is that Flat Howard is doing what our 12-year-old considers to be Dean’s signature finger stance. (You’ll need the Real Player unfortunately.)
Categories: politics Date: November 25th, 2003
November 24, 2003
Decisiveness and PassionIn Heidegger’s Children, Richard Wolin quotes Hans Jonas on why he should have seen Heidegger’s Nazism earlier: it’s embedded in Heidegger’s talk of “resoluteness” and “decisiveness.” Says Jonas, whereas Heidegger accused idealist philosophy of being a step removed from the world,
If this is right (and it’s been too long since I read Being and Time to be sure), it means Heidegger gives us no way of distinguishing a “resolute decision” to support the worst of German nationalism from a decision to work in a refugee camp or to definitely go on the Atkins diet next year. I seem to recall this Cluetrain book that talks about the importance of passion. And in that it’s echoing Tom Peters’ call for passionate commitment to serving one’s customers. (I like Peters’ new book, Re-Imagine, btw.) Isn’t Cluetrain guilty of the same content-free call for a form of commitment? Granted, we’re not talking about Nazism here, but what do you do with a pointy-haired boss who is passionate about creating a truly oppressive, soul-less business environment for the people who report to him? It’d be foollish to deny that PHB’s can ever be passionate. There are Taylorist guys with stopwatches dedicated to squeezing the life out of an organization who are completely committed to what they’re doing: They spend their spare time reading about it, they can’t wait to tell you about it, and they sleep well at night convinced that every day they’re making the world a little better. So, no, passion isn’t enough. Passionate oppression is no better than dispassionate oppression. (It might be worse. I don’t know.) But decisiveness is often the opposite of passion. It wants to end the suspense and take an act, any act. It doesn’t like the doubt and uncertainty that is built into passion because decisiveness doesn’t like possibility. It wants the future to be nailed down, and the decision is the first bang of the hammer. Decisiveness is essentially disengaged from the openness that is the future. Passion is the embrace of that openness. Just think about the difference between a manager who is overly-decisive and one who is passionate about the company’s reason for existence. Passion by itself isn’t enough: Some of them Nazis were pretty damn passionate. But pound for pound, I’ll take passion over decisiveness any day.
Categories: misc Date: November 24th, 2003
Dean of VirtualityEdward Castronova is looking for a university dean who wants to house a Center for the Study of Synthetic Worlds. If you wonder whether there’s useful academic work to be done by such a center, check the Terranova group blog.
Categories: web Date: November 24th, 2003
RFH: Battery shocker[RFH= Request for Help] I bought a big, fat Sony lithium-ion battery (NP-FS21) for my digital video camera two years ago. Now, after fairly minimal use, it’s dead, Jim. When I plug it into the recharger, the charge light comes on for about 15 seconds. The thing just doesn’t take a charge. Any ideas about how to regenerate it? Failing that, does anyone have any recommendations for offbrand batteries that actually work from vendors who don’t suck?
Categories: tech Date: November 24th, 2003
November 23, 2003
Street ArtHas everyone already seen this photo of Kurt Wenner’s street paintings? Well, then you can just see them again…
Categories: misc Date: November 23rd, 2003
FBI Scrutinizing Anti-War Protestors">FBI Scrutinizing Anti-War ProtestorsHello! That’s me, the 107,356th person back, just to the left of that nice old man in the green baseball cap. Helloooo!
Categories: politics Date: November 23rd, 2003
November 22, 2003
Kudos to Wired and moreWired’s on a roll. In the October issue, they ran a page by Rebecca Harper that puts the effect of music sharing into perspective: The labels have released 14% fewer new CDs since 1999 and they’ve raised the prices 16% since 1997 (after adjusting for inflation). Yes, she says, file sharing has cost the industry money. “But what the RIAA doesn’t want to admit is that the CD is reaching the end of its life cycle…” Then in the December issue (the one with Uma on the cover), they devote a part of a page to step-by-step instructions on how to make a copy of DVD. And while we’re on the topic(s): 1. Don’t miss Larry Lessig’s Wired piece on user-owned fiber to the home. 2. LOCA is a new music label that’s trying to do it right: the music is free but the CD’s gonna cost you. Worth a look, a listen and maybe some bucks. 3. I’m off to buy the latest Dixie Chicks CD. I first listened to them because of The Controversy. Turns out I like them.
Categories: misc Date: November 22nd, 2003
November 21, 2003
Kucinich the PirateDennis Kucinich has posted the memos that Diebold claims we may not be post because Diebold doesn’t want us talking about possible vulnerabilities in its electronic voting machines. Nice move, DK! (And good blogging by Donna at Copyfight.) Correction: According to Dan Gillmor, DK’s page has links to sites with copies of the Diebold memos, not the memos themselves.
Categories: politics Date: November 21st, 2003
Linux for DeskflopsAmy Wohl’s always excellent — and free — newsletter reports on a Linux for Desktops conference:
Usability? Hah! If you want to see the barrier to desktop Linux’s acceptance, watch over my shoulder one day as I try to use KDE or Gnome to do ordinary tasks such as keeping my MP3 player running if any other sound is emitted (oh yeah, guessing which processes are audio ones so that I can then manually Kill them hoping that I got the right one is reaaaal user friendly) or downloading and installing a new application. Fabulous end user experiences. Lord love Linux and godspeed to it, but desktop Linux is so Windows 3.0.
Categories: tech Date: November 21st, 2003
Pre-RefusingI’ve was asked yesterday to pre-register for an event because of security concerns. (Jonathan Sacks, the chief rabbi of England is speaking.) I’m refusing. Oh, I’m happy to register. But I draw the line at pre-registering unless I’m registering before the registration process begins.
Categories: misc Date: November 21st, 2003
Patent ProgressFrom Living Networks (the book) by Ross Dawson comes this Fun Fact:
How brutal and primitive! Now, of course, we take a much more civilized approach to patent infringement: We sue, destroying not just the boat but the factory, the business, the distributors’ business, and the future ability of all those who ever worked on the infringing object to earn a living ever again…unless of course the boat could be used for terrorist purposes in which case we can whisk the inventor and manufacturer away to get a twelve year tan at Guantanamo. BTW, the source Ross cites says that before this first patent, inventors and scientists “used ciphers such as Leonardo’s mirror-image script” to protect their ideas. Now, of course, writing backwards violates the US PATRIOT Act.
Categories: politics Date: November 21st, 2003
November 20, 2003
Down the slippery slopeJeff Jacoby is a conservative columnist in the Boston Globe. His response today (link will break tomorrow) to the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court’s ruling permitting gay marriage is to warn us — Sanctorumly — that we’ve started down a slippery slope towards polygamy and incest. After all, he writes, one of the dissenting judges said that state’s equal rights amendment was cited in the Court’s decision, and the Boston Globe in 1976 had dismissed the claim that “the amendment would…legitimize marriage between people of the same sex.” Yet, 27 years later, that’s exactly what’s happened. Likewise, in 1989, the Globe editorialized that the gay rights law does not “put Massachusetts on a ’slippery slope’ towards” a right to gay marriage. Cool research. But I seem not to be following Jacoby’s logic here. The ERA of the Massachusetts Constitution started us down a slippery slope that has led to gay marriage. This is evidence that the gay marriage ruling will lead us down a slippery slope to polygamy and incest. Thus the gay marriage ruling is bad. That’s his reasoning, right? But doesn’t that logic also mean that the ERA was bad? Does Jacoby really want to maintain that guaranteeing equal rights for women was a bad thing for the state? “Equality under the law shall not be denied or abridged because of sex, race, color, creed or national origin.” Yeah, there’s a slope we should be afraid to get on. Who knows where it could lead? And there’s an argument just as good as Jacoby’s that says that the 15th Amendment started us down the slippery slope to the ERA. Damn Abolitionists! You know, there’s a reason why the slippery slope argument is classified as a fallacy. Jacoby’s just illustrated it.
Categories: politics Date: November 20th, 2003
Spewing PiratesThe S.P.E.W. Factor is what most of the contributors to the Word Pirates page think Word Pirates is about. (Thanks to Tom Wilson for the link.)
Categories: misc Date: November 20th, 2003
Shows You the MoneyHere’s a map that shows you where each candidate’s money is coming from. Interesting. (Thanks to Darhl Stultz for the link.)
Categories: politics Date: November 20th, 2003
November 19, 2003
The Value of Thin ConnectionsI’ve been guest blogging at the Corante Many2Many site and just posted an entry on how non-rich connections enable social networks.
Categories: tech Date: November 19th, 2003
Dean on “ReRegulation” and a social contractAn article in the Boston Globe (online today and tomorrow only) reports on an interview with Dean in which he calls for “reregulation“:
Go Dean! And, Gov. Dean gave an important speech yesterday that talks about the economic issues that (from my point of view) underly the question of whether the economy is trending up or down this month. Some snippets without context:
Worth reading in full. PS: At our get-together last night, 15 of us wrote 100 letters to undecided voters in Iowa. Feels good to write the letters and even better to meet a diverse group of Dean supporters.
Categories: politics Date: November 19th, 2003
The Dream Comes TrueBack in 1995, I was VP of Strategic Marketing at Open Text, which at the time was 25-person SGML indexing company. The company had initially built itself on a single lead project in the late ’80s: Indexing the Oxford English Dictionary. Doing a full-text index of such a massive work was considered impossible. Who could dream of indexing tens of thousands of pages, hundreds of thousands of words? But under the technical direction of Tim Bray, breakthroughs were made and full-text retrieval took an important step forward. Fifteen years later, Tim Bray and Open Text have moved onto other challenges. But only now has the fruit of that original effort paid off in full. Yes, the latest issue of WordWays, the oddest journal on the planet, announces that computer-aided searches of the OED have found 523 of the 625 vowel tetragrams. A vowel tetragram, in the words of Susan Thorpe of Great Missenden, England, the author of the article, is “a group of 4 vowels unbroken by consonants.” She suggests that AQUEOUS, QUEUE, ONOMATOPOEIA, COOEE, HAWAIIAN and SEQUOIA “are perhaps the most familiar.” For example, I recently found myself saying, “The aqueous Hawaiian and great sequoia stood in a queue to ask, in onomatopoeia, what the hell a cooee is.” Thorpe has unearthed other familiar words such as EEEEVE (the iiwi bird), BEOUIEN (tremble), IUAEIN (to hate), OUOUO (no stinting), UIUIA (type of beer), PLOIIER (ply), and MEAOUSTE (see Miaotse). If you know of words that contain UIII, OIIU, OOOU, AAAO, AUUU and about 100 others, Susan wants to hear from you. Ah, yes, it’s the kind of day that makes your hard work figuring out how to use B-trees to encode arbitrary SGML data seem all worthwhile…
Categories: misc Date: November 19th, 2003
November 18, 2003
Surprisingly HappyI support gay marriage yet I found myself made unexpectedly happy by the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court’s ruling. I’m elated. Woohoo! I like marriage. It’s a great thing when it works: being married has made my life into something even I like. And I no longer can see what the serious objections are to gay marriage, assuming that “Seeing men kiss on the lips is creepy” doesn’t count as a serious objection. So, let me repeat: Woohoo! (And now begins the fight to avoid a constitutional amendment that would annul today’s joy. Sigh.)
Categories: politics Date: November 18th, 2003
Ed Cone on the Dean CampaignEd’s written an excellent and thorough article on what’s different about the Dean campaign, especially as seen through the lens of marketing. For example:
Categories: web Date: November 18th, 2003
FrichésFrom Lockergnome comes this link to a page that shows the equivalent clichés in French and English. E.g., “He’s knee-high to a grasshopper” in French is “He’s tall like three apples…
Categories: humor Date: November 18th, 2003
The socio-political infrastructureI’m continuing to guest blog at the Corante Many-to-Many site and just posted something on which parts of the new social/political network being created during this campaign season are likely to survive the campaign.
Categories: politics Date: November 18th, 2003
November 17, 2003
Havel on the soul of democracyJay Rosen, in a fine piece on what’s wrong with politics, quotes Vaclav Havel:
And here’s a snipped from Jay:
But don’t be satisfied with snippets! It’s a damn fine piece. Rick Klau, well-known Deaniac, has a report that’s partisan yet open-minded and observant, about the Jefferson Jackson Day Dinner where most of the Democratic candidates showed up. (Telling detail: It took 43 buses to bring the Dean supporters in; the campaign had to get a parade permit just to let them to roll in.)
Categories: politics Date: November 17th, 2003
Old white guy’s reproductive rightsPeter Kaminski runs the Reuters photo of Bush signing the “partial birth” abortion ban. It is striking, as Pete says, because all the on-lookers at this photo opp are dignified old white men. Hey, thanks, guys! Pete’s also got some cogent comments on the bill.
Categories: politics Date: November 17th, 2003
Send Back Your MP3sHere’s a site that every youngster who’s ever downloaded an illegal MP3 must visit. It changed my life. I think it just might change yours. Dave’s concerned that someone might take this idea seriously even though the site is scrupulously careful to give only absurd instructions on how to do what it satirically suggests. (Let me emphatically agree with him: Yes, sending mp3s through the mail would be a hideous and stupid waste of bits.) I like his counter idea of cutting up your CDs and sending them back to the record companies, though. But I need ‘em for backup!
Categories: web Date: November 17th, 2003
Every 8 secondsDave Sifry of Technorati writes:
Every 0.86 seconds?? Man, I’m really going to have to step up my pace! (Thanks, Dave, for providing such an outstanding service to us all.)
Categories: web Date: November 17th, 2003
November 16, 2003
e-ZoharAt last! The Zohar is online! As it is writ (on the Web page):
Joseph Zitt, in an email message, explains:
My Aramaic is a little rusty (that is, I used to know how to spell “Aramaic” with confidence but now I have to look it up), but it is definitely very cool to see the Lit Web get lit up a little bit more.
Categories: misc Date: November 16th, 2003
Writing letters for DeanHalley wonders if the letter-writing event I’m hosting is still on for this Tuesday. And how! It’s at 7pm and if you’re in the Boston area and feel like coming by to write letters to undecided voters in Iowa about why you’re supporting Dean, you’re invited. Send me an email for the details.
Categories: politics Date: November 16th, 2003
November 15, 2003
West Wing Better?Good discussion this morning on NPR’s Weekend Edition about whether The West Wing has improved this season after the departure of creator and genius Adam Sorkin. I think it has. I thought the conclusion of the opening episodes featuring the fabulous John Goodman was strong when it turned out [SPOILER AHEAD] that Josh’s fears about Republican abuses were in fact just projections of his own overly-political worldview. The inklings of a legitimate opposition strengthen the show. On the other hand, the melodramatic split between the president and the first lady seems pretty contrived to me. And there was one moment that Sorkin would never ever have allowed in: Josh stopping a cab so he can yell to the Capitol dome: “You wanna piece of me?” Just plain embarrassing.
Categories: misc Date: November 15th, 2003
|