On the one hand, a new peer-reviewed open access journal is starting up: The Journal of Media and Communication Studies. It’s promising to work toward a four-week decision process for submitted articles, with publication in the next issue. Good luck to JMCS.
On the other hand, Jonathan Zittrain blogs about a European journal currently being sued because it refused to give in to an author’s demand that a short, critical book review be removed. The editor’s courteous, respectful, generous response is here. (I posted about this when Harry Lewis blogged about it earlier.)
Just to give you a sense of how “libelous” the book is, here’s its final paragraph:
Karin Calvo-Goller has undoubtedly invested much time and effort into this book, which â€“ but for regrettably sloppy editing â€“ might well serve as a first systematic introduction to the procedural issues confronting the ICC. What is still missing is a book that might help to resolve these issues.
Oh why can’t we all just get along?