Joho the BlogRe-reading Hornblower - Joho the Blog

Re-reading Hornblower

I read all of C.S. Forester’s Horatio Hornblower series when I was in high school.

I’m on a week of vacation — i.e., a nicer place to work — and have been re-reading them.

Why isn’t everyone re-reading them? They’re wonderful. Most of the seafaring descriptions are opaque to me, but it doesn’t matter. The stories are character-based and Forester is great at expressing personality succinctly, as well as taking us deep into Hornblower’s character over the course of the books. Besides, all the talk of binneys ’round the blaggard binge don’t get in the way of understanding the action

Some prefer Patrick O’Brian’s Aubrey-Maturin “Master and Commander” series. They are wrong. I believe the Internet when it says O’Brian’s battles are more realistic because they’re based on actual events. I don’t care. I do care, however, about O’Brian’s clumsy construction of his main characters. I can sense the author trying to inflate them into three dimensions. Then they’re given implausible roles and actions.

Of course you may disagree with me entirely about that. But here’s the killer for me: O’Brian relies on long pages of back-and-forth dialogue…while not telling you who’s talking. I don’t like having to count back by twos to find the original speaker. All I need is an occasional, “‘Me, neither,’ said Jack.” Is that asking too much?

Anyway, take a look at Hornblower and the Atropos to see if you’re going to like the series. That begins with a few chapters of Hornblower arranging the logistics for the flotilla portion of Lord Nelson’s funeral. If you find yourself as engrossed in chapters about logistics as I did, you’re probably hooked forever.

One Response to “Re-reading Hornblower”

  1. Agreed! I like both series, but the Aubrey-Maturin universe takes a lot more work.

    Incidentally, let me recommend the C. Northcote Parkinson’s “biography” of Hornblower: http://amzn.to/2soyweE as well as King and Hattendorf’s dictionary for O’Brian’s books: http://amzn.to/2u64mKi

    Both are great when rereading (or, for that matter reading) the books – it gives the nerdy reader somewhere to dive when stuck on what a capstan is or how the enclose laws work….

    Espen


Web Joho only

Comments (RSS).  RSS icon